Some policies allow customers to renew their term life insurance,...

Some policies allow customers to renew their term life insurance, typically at a higher premium that reflects their age.  Credit: Getty Images/time99lek

Long Islanders whose term life insurance policy is expiring have several options for keeping coverage but could face much higher premiums as they age.

Unlike most permanent life insurance policies, term life insurance coverage lasts for a specific window of time, often between 10 to 30 years. 

Some policies allow customers to renew their term insurance, typically at a higher premium that reflects their age. Others could shop for a new term policy. 

Consumers could buy permanent life insurance or convert their term policy to permanent coverage, if their policy includes that option. 

They also could opt to let the policy expire and take on the financial risk of an untimely death using their own assets and investments.

The right decision is dependent on a person’s financial circumstances, age and comfort with risk, said David Frisch, CEO of Frisch Financial Group in Melville.

But some Long Islanders might be weighing the cost of life insurance against essential needs like paying for heating oil and may choose to postpone a purchase, he said.

“Each family’s decision is very personal,” Frisch said. “Some families are going to say, ‘No matter what it costs to protect my family, I'm willing to pay that price.’ "

The percentage of Americans with a life insurance policy, including coverage through their employer, has long been declining and dropped to 52% this year from 60% in 2016. That's according to data from LIMRA, a Windsor, Connecticut-based life insurance industry trade association.

Some of the factors contributing to the decline include younger generations getting married and having their first child later, according to LIMRA.

Consumers also face competing financial priorities including paying off student loan debt and saving for a house, said Karen Terry, director of LIMRA Insurance Research.

But ownership has risen since the pandemic, she said.

“Anything that's going to raise people's awareness of their own mortality is going to raise interest in a product like insurance,” she said.

Financial planners and life insurance experts who spoke with Newsday weighed the pros and cons of those options, explained key concepts consumers need to know and discussed mistakes to avoid.

Should consumers renew their term policy or buy a new policy?

The first question policyholders should ask is why they purchased coverage in the first place, Frisch said.

Common reasons to buy life insurance include paying for childcare, mortgage expenses or college costs, he said. If those expenses are still a factor, some individuals might purchase another term policy. 

But consumers should be aware that renewing a term policy in your 50s or buying a new one can be significantly more expensive, said Craig Ferrantino, president of Craig James Financial Services in Melville.

How much more expensive does coverage get as you age?

One analysis by personal finance website NerdWallet found the average rate quote was 3.8 times higher for a male 50-year-old and 3.5 times higher for a female 50-year-old when compared with a 30-year-old of the same gender.

Those quotes were for nonsmokers in good health seeking a 20-year term life insurance policy with $500,000 in coverage.

However, rates can vary widely based on a person’s health, family medical history, driving record and the risk of their occupation, NerdWallet data shows.

Some carriers offer life insurance without a medical exam, but those policies have higher annual premiums on average, according to NerdWallet.

What are the pros and cons of opting for term versus permanent insurance?

Term life insurance offers a cheaper option for younger consumers to protect against an early demise. The policy has no cash value and only pays out if a person dies during the term, according to NerdWallet.

Whole life insurance, one type of permanent insurance, is more expensive but builds cash value over time that could be borrowed against in the future. 

The goal of permanent insurance is often geared toward leaving an inheritance, protecting a surviving spouse or covering taxes on wealth transfers to beneficiaries, Frisch said.

Ferrantino said he encourages term life insurance buyers to pay a higher premium for a policy that has a rider allowing them to convert it to permanent insurance at the end of the term. That can protect policyholders in the event they're diagnosed with a serious health condition.

“You're taking a risk of not being able to be insured or being insured at a different rate” that’s typically higher as you age, he said. 

How much coverage does a person need?

Fidelity Investments recommends buying coverage worth 10 to 12 times your annual income. But the company describes several approaches to tailor that guideline to a person’s needs.

One method involves multiplying annual income by the number of years your family would need financial support, according to Fidelity. Another focuses on obligations, such as debt and living expenses.

The purpose of life insurance is to transfer the financial risk from one's family to the insurance company, Frisch said.

A person might forego buying another policy, he said, if they determine they have adequate assets to cover the financial risk to their family or if they opt to direct money toward other investments.

What mistakes should you avoid?

When buying insurance to replace an expiring policy, it’s best not to wait until the last minute, Frisch said.

Starting the process before a policy lapses allows consumers to compare the potential cost of staying with a current insurer or selecting a new policy.

Life insurance buyers can be particularly vulnerable to this type of decision paralysis, Frisch said.

“Dealing with mortality of any kind — whether it's death, disability, going into a nursing home — it's a very emotional topic, and sometimes people just don't want to deal with it,” Frisch said. 

Consumers should also avoid missing a payment that could put them at risk of termination, typically after a grace period, Ferrantino said.

Most carriers allow for reinstatement during a certain time period if you make back payments plus interest, according to Experian. 

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME