Why embroidery is Long Island's hottest fashion trend

Kelsy McLary holds a custom embroidered blazer for a client's wedding in her shop, Lindenhurst General Store inside the Holy Black barbershop in Lindenhurst. Credit: Elizabeth Sagarin
In September, Kristen Johnson hosted her besties at her home in Garden City for a get-together that would make Jane Austen characters smile. The main event, alongside drinks and snacks: a hand-embroidery workshop.
"It was a different take on a girls night," says Johnson, 41, who got hooked on embroidery early last year and wanted to share the joy of it. "There’s something really beautiful about learning a new skill with your friends."
Once associated with grandmothers and heirlooms, hand embroidery is being reframed. The pastime is finding a new generation of fans looking for screen-free creativity, relaxation and a personal approach to fashion that makes space for imperfection.
By the end of the 2 ½-hour gathering, the eight women had stitched initials and basic designs into sweatshirts and felt the buzz that comes from time well spent and artistic accomplishment.
"You can’t be distracted when you’re embroidering," said Johnson. "You really just stay focused. It’s very calming and very satisfying."
And very popular. A 2026 creativity trend report for Michaels, the arts and crafts retail chain, released in March found that searches for analog hobbies done without digital devices, including embroidery, had grown 136% over six months.

Jessica Penley teaches hand embroidery through her business Letter Party. Credit: Letter Party
Expressing individuality
Jessica Penley, owner of Letter Party, an embroidery business that specializes in on-site tutorials and DIY kits, led Johnson’s workshop. She brought tops to personalize, hoops, colorful threads, needles, and yards of stitching know-how.
"The individual aspect of hand embroidery is an essential part of its appeal," says Penley, 40, of Rockville Centre. "You can make clothing and other items all your own, it’s no longer just something generic."
After being furloughed from interior design work during COVID, Penley began embroidering clothes and gifts and opened an Etsy shop. She now travels to customer locations, shops and brand events. Workshops run around $85-$95.
In an era of machine mass production, hand embroidery is about individuality: every stitch adds up to something customized and even quietly luxurious. Tiny flaws? Sew what.
"When I teach workshops, people are often like, ‘Oh, it’s not perfect,’" states Penley. "I always say, ‘You don’t want it to be perfect. You don't want it to look like you bought it on Amazon. You want people to know that you made this by hand. That’s what makes it special. That’s what makes it you."
Kelsy McLary chain stitches a custom designed embroidery piece in her shop, Lindenhurst General Store. Credit: Elizabeth Sagarin
Stitch in store
Kelsy McLary, 31, owner of Lindenhurst General Store, concurs. The 6-month-old shop’s busy Stitch Bar offers custom chain stitch hand embroidery to personalize clothing, bags and accessories bought in the store or elsewhere.
Lettering is the most common request, including names, nicknames, initials, and phrases like "Team Suffolk Swim." Customers also ask for flowers, hearts and other designs. Hand embroidery starts at $18 for small designs or three letters.
"I do a ton of baby gifts and bridal jeans with the bride’s new last name," says McLary. "Minuscule details can be changed and made to fit for the person, which makes everything unique and personal."
McLary has honed her hand embroidery skills since she was 18. Years of practice have improved the speed and consistency of her stitching style that often recalls elegant calligraphy.
"When I talk to people about what I do, they often assume that there has to be a machine at some point," she says. "Once I tell them it's all by hand, their eyes kind of flicker. It adds another layer to the creativity and the work behind everything."

Frank Acevedo, owner of Village Tattoo in Bethpage, in his hand-embroidered jacket stitched by Kelsy McLary. Credit: Village Tattoo
Frank Acevedo, 60, co-owner of Village Tattoo in Bethpage, found his eyes widening after enlisting McLary to customize a nylon blue and gold bomber coat. "The jacket cost five bucks," says Avecedo. " I grabbed it out of a vintage store."
His original plan was to have McLary embellish it with large V and T patches. After collaborating with her, he had her spell out "Village Tattoo" on the back and "Frank" in the front by hand. "I’ve never been happier," Acevedo says. "It’s a really cool feeling whenever I wear it. No one else has this jacket."
At Hitch, a clothing and gifts boutique in Babylon, hand embroidery is a way to let stitches do the talking. "Initials and dates on sleeves are super trendy for new relationships or anniversary and wedding gifts," says owner Joseph DeBello. The service runs around $15 and up. The shop periodically runs embroidery workshops they post in advance on Instagram.

Custom embroidered hats are all the rage this season. A custom hat seen at Hitch in Babylon. Credit: Newsday/Kristen Sullivan
The hand-embroidery aesthetic is evolving beyond pretty and playful motifs and lettering to simply adorn items. Colorful stitching and visible mending gives worn clothes a second life.
At Liza’s Lace Atelier vintage shop in Southhold, owner Brigitte Quinn, 29, uses hand embroidery for creative cover-ups for clothes and other items in the store. Prices run $15-$600.
"I’d gotten a cotton nightgown Florence, Italy with little rust stains from pins used to keep appliqués in place," says Quinn. "I couldn’t get the rust stains out, so I embroidered little rosettes all over the garment, not just at the stains."
Quinn was drawn to the craft two years ago, and her passion has grown alongside its surge in popularity. Now, she’s planning to bring an instructor into her store to lead an embroidery workshop.
Hand-embroidery insiders understand why the craft is booming. It’s affordable, beginner-friendly for all ages and it puts creative self-expression at your fingertips.
"I’m really passionate about what I do," says McLary. "I’ve seen this phrase — ‘Handmade is the new luxury’ — going around a lot lately. Since opening my store, it’s resonated more than ever."
4 spots for hand embroidery
- Letter Party, letterpartyshop.com, Instagram: @letterpartyshop
- Lindenhurst General Store, 168 N. Wellwood Ave., Lindenhurst, lindenhurstgeneral.com, Instagram: @lindenhurstgeneral
- Liza’s Lace Atelier, 85 Beckwith Ave., Southold, 631-487-2283, Lizaslace.com, Instagram: @Lizas.lace
- Hitch, 37 E. Main St., Babylon; 516-519-2494, hitchlongisland.com, Instagram: @hitchli