Cheryl Bergenstock convicted in head-on DWI crash that killed former News12 reporter Alan Goldsand

Cheryl Bergenstock appears at the Nassau County Court House in Mineola on Oct. 26. Credit: Newsday/James Carbone
A Nassau County jury convicted a Bethpage woman on Wednesday of killing a beloved classical violinist and former News12 reporter in a 2024 head-on drunk driving crash.
Cheryl Bergenstock, 66, was found guilty of aggravated vehicular homicide, three counts of vehicular manslaughter, aggravated driving while intoxicated and other charges after she crossed the center line on Round Swamp Road in Bethpage on June 28, 2024, smashing head-on into Alan Goldsand’s red Toyota Corolla.
Prosecutors said Bergenstock began drinking that Friday around 5 p.m. and had consumed nearly an entire 750ml bottle of Malibu rum mixed with orange juice at a friend’s house before getting behind the wheel of her car to drive home.
Her friend offered her a lift home and said she would call Bergenstock’s husband to pick her up, to prevent her from driving, according to assistant district attorney Alexandria Laird.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- Cheryl Bergenstock, 66, of Bethpage, was convicted on Wednesday of aggravated vehicular homicide for the 2024 drunk driving crash that killed former News12 reporter Alan Goldsand
- Prosecutors said Bergenstock drank nearly and entire bottle of Malibu rum and refused a ride home before the fatal crash
- Goldsand performed in several community orchestras as a violinist and was the second ranking member of the Jewish War Veterans Post 655 in Plainview
Her blood alcohol content was 0.20, more than double the legal limit to drive in New York, court records show.
Bergenstock, of Bethpage, was seen weaving as she headed home alone, prosecutors said, her car’s data recorder clocked her doing 78 mph in a 40 mph zone, nearly double the speed limit, just before the crash.
The evidence also showed that she never touched the brake pedal as she crossed the double yellow line and smashed head-on into Goldsand, 82, on Round Swamp Road in Bethpage.
After the crash, as she was being treated for her injuries, she told authorities that she was “really, really drunk.”
The jury deliberated for less than three hours before coming back with a guilty verdict. State Supreme Court Justice Helene Gugerty remanded her into jail custody after the verdict was read.
Bergenstock's lawyer, Steve Politi, said he will appeal the verdict.
"We have no choice but to respect the jury's verdict," he said. "We do not believe that the people proved their case. The judge made a lot of rulings. We believe that there were a number of errors made. We believe that our client was deprived of her right to a fair trial."
Juliet Goldsand, the victim’s daughter, took the stand early in the trial to testify about her father’s extensive injuries.
Doctors in the hospital for less than 24 hours before he died, she said. He never regained consciousness for her to talk to him.

Alan Goldsand Credit: Alan Goldsand
“There's some level of solace and closure for me and my father's loved ones knowing that justice has finally been served after two and half years of waiting; however, nothing will ever diminish the heartbreak and outrage of knowing that this tragedy was 100% preventable,” his daughter said in a statement. “I hope this will serve as a warning and reminder to as many as possible that if you've been drinking or someone suggests you are not fit to drive, it's a lot less inconvenient to pick up your car in the morning then to kill someone and spend a good chunk of the rest of your life in prison. At least she'll be off the road for good now. I do also hope that lawmakers will finally update and increase the penalties for drunk driving offenses, especially when innocent people are injured or killed.”
Friends of Alan Goldsand recalled him as “a mensch.”
One of the first New12 reporters and former president of the New York Financial Writer’s Association, where he channeled his love of music in their annual “Financial Follies” dinner and show where they spoof the past year’s financial news.
He was also a U.S. Army veteran, where he was stationed at Ft. Dix, New Jersey and then Ft. Hood, Texas, where he played violin in the band during the Vietnam War, his family said.
More recently, he became the senior vice commander of the Jewish War Veterans, Post 655 in Plainview.
“He was such a good guy,” said William Davidson, the JWV post commander and a former federal agent. “[He was] the type of guy that you would want to live right next door to you and be a family friend and sit down at the dinner table. I can't express that it was such an immense loss for the post, but beyond that, just a loss, period.”
Bergenstock faces 8 1/3 to 25 years in prison at her sentencing on Jan. 5.
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game

