Sachem High School East student, 15, indicted in school stabbing that left 16-year-old critically injured

Security outside Sachem High East in Farmingville where a student was stabbed on Nov. 5. Credit: Newsday/James Carbone
A 15-year-old Sachem High School East student was indicted Tuesday on charges he allegedly stabbed another student in the chest during a school fight earlier this month, Suffolk prosecutors announced.
The student, whom Newsday is not naming due to his age, was arraigned on a first-degree felony assault charge. He was held on $500,000 cash bail, $1 million bond or $1.5 million partially secured bond.
The 16-year-old who was stabbed, remains in the intensive care unit at Stony Brook University Hospital after undergoing lifesaving surgery, according to the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office.
According to prosecutors, school security had separated the pair then the 15-year-old pulled out a knife, rushed toward the victim and stabbed him in the chest, leaving him seriously wounded.
"Any violence in schools is absolutely unacceptable," Suffolk District Attorney Ray Tierney said in a release. "A teenager now faces a serious felony charge for allegedly resorting to a knife to settle a fist fight, leaving another young man critically injured. No disagreement, argument or moment of anger justifies this kind of violence."
Defense attorney Robert Levinson, of the Suffolk County Legal Aid Society, previously argued in court there was more to the case and it was "not an unprovoked attack."
Authorities said the fight took place Nov. 5 in the school parking lot following dismissal at 2 p.m. In a video previously shared with Newsday, the boys are seen coming to blows while a large crowd of students surrounds them. Some scream, "Oh my God!" and laugh.
On the video, a security guard in a reflective yellow jacket then steps in and someone is heard yelling "break it up, break it up," while the pair of students continue punching each other. The defendant falls to the ground and students laugh.
The security guard is seen intervening seconds later and pulls the alleged victim off the defendant. But the defendant then gets up and rushes at the other teen. The security guard tries to kick him away, but the defendant appears to stab the student while two other guards run up to restrain him.
Sachem Superintendent Patti Trombetta previously said the district would continue working with its security team and police to address any concerns in the community.
The 15-year-old is due back in court Dec. 2. A conviction could carry a sentence of 10 years in prison as a juvenile offender.



