These 2026 high school seniors have received Newsday First Team All-Long Island status; no second team athletes are listed. The following sports did not have All-Long Island Teams selected before this section went to print: badminton, baseball, flag football, boys and girls golf, boys and girls lacrosse, softball, boys tennis, and boys and girls track.

2025-2026 Newsday All-Long Island First Team senior athletes

Basketball, boys

Ryan Leary, Carle Place HS
Michael Cascione, Smithtown West HS
Amir Dickerson, Amityville HS
Kyle Dillon, Chaminade HS
Corey Faines, Bay Shore HS
Alex Franklin, Southampton HS
Brendan Martin, Floral Park HS
Melo Mojeed, St. Dominic HS
Tristan Thomas, Holy Trinity HS

Basketball, girls

Kayla Solomon, St. Mary’s HS
Mia Betancourt, Mt. Sinai HS
Meaghan Campbell, MacArthur HS
Sandra Clarke, Westhampton HS
Maeve Downing, New Hyde Park HS
Alyssa Polonia, Baldwin HS
Samantha Schneider, Syosset HS
Destiny Robinson, St. Mary’s HS

Bowling, boys

Andrew Ceraulo, Seaford HS
Gavin Connell, Islip HS
Luke Jovans, Commack HS
Andrew Schaefer, Commack HS
Logan Silbert, Eastport-South Manor HS
Alex Silbert, Eastport-South Manor HS

Bowling, girls

Brooke Andresen, East Islip HS
Abby Buenaventura, MacArthur HS
Carissa Lugares, Commack HS

Cheerleading

Alex Cerna, Whitman HS
Reese Gillen, Farmingdale HS
Mya Grayson, Freeport HS
Jasmin Lawrence, Farmingdale HS
Ian Licavoli, Ward Melville HS
Kaitlyn Lieberman, Smithtown West HS
Mia Stimac, Division HS
Ava Verderosa, West Islip HS
Lizzie Marino, Floyd HS

Cross Country, boys

Anthony Anatol, Ward Melville HS
Ian Frazer, Wantagh HS
Zach Greene, Oyster Bay HS
Brian Guiheen, Chaminade HS
Blake Sealy, Manhasset HS
Ross Wallace, Uniondale HS
Dylan Walsh, Sayville HS

Cross Country, girls

Olivia DiGaetano, Connetquot HS
Maeve Going, Sacred Heart HS
Joanna Kenney, North Shore HS
Maggie McCormick, Bay Shore HS

Field Hockey

Shannon Carney, Bayport-Blue Point HS
Kate Comiskey, Patchogue-Medford HS
Hadley Torre, Ward Melville HS
Aliya Hassett, Massapequa HS
Taylor Murtha, Eastport-South Manor HS
Emily Racich, Garden City HS
Eden Randall, Manhasset HS
Averie Smith, Garden City HS
Brooke Wasson, Sachem East HS

Football

Dylan Bayer, East Islip HS
Jovan Bonilla, East Islip HS
Greyson Cabrera, Northport HS
Michael Cascione, Smithtown West HS
Patrick Coan, Sayville HS
Trevon Cole-Jenkins, Half Hollow Hills East HS
Brian Falk, Seaford HS
Ethan Lawless, Huntington HS
Jeru Hall, William Floyd HS
Ethan Lawless, Huntington HS
Ryan Leary, Carle Place HS
Declan Miller, Chaminade HS
Kevin Moore, St. Anthony’s HS
Luke Neugebauer, Sayville HS
Joe Nicholson, Wantagh HS
Zach Olson, Garden City HS
Zack Silva, Long Beach HS
Jake Simmons, East Islip HS
Tristan Tarasi, Massapequa HS
Aidan Winter, Babylon HS

Fencing, boys

William Dreyer, Ward Melville HS
Justin Guo, Syosset HS
Brandon Lim, Syosset HS

Fencing, girls

Shelly Banegas, Lindenhurst HS
Esha Nayak, Syosset HS
Gabriella Sherlock, Oyster Bay HS

Gymnastics, girls

Sophia Bahiri, Syosset HS
Bayla Goldberg, Smithtown HS
Avery Melchiona, Connetquot HS
Abbey Thaler, Carle Place/Wheatley HS

Ice Hockey

Anthony Cutalo, St. Anthony’s HS
JT Caruso, Northport HS
Jonathan Wheeler, Walt Whitman HS
Mikey Johnson, Chaminade HS
Declan Munkwitz, Comsewogue HS
Jordan Valcich, St. Anthony’s HS
Nate Pitman, Chaminade HS

Soccer, boys

Diego Argueta, Brentwood HS
Ferenc Bagi, Commack HS
Elliot Burgueno, Ward Melville HS
Jack Dorsey, Chaminade HS
Thomas Fargione, Garden City HS
Dylan Fisher, Garden City HS
Cooper Kassan, Glenn HS
Jack Klein, Garden City HS
Robert Malave, Chaminade HS
Brayden O’Boyle, Commack HS

Soccer, girls

Briana Ciccone, Garden City HS
Mia Claro, Kellenberg HS
Brooke Doreste, South Side HS
Maeve Gayer, Eastport-South Manor HS
Mia Mangano, Shoreham-Wading River HS
Danika Tidridge, East Islip HS
Leah Tomeo, West Islip HS
Ryann Zandor, Oceanside HS

Swimming, boys

Gavin Buckley, Chaminade HS
Matt Chang, Herricks HS
Tyler Gallub, Smithtown/Hauppauge HS
Trevor Green, Rocky Point HS
Andrew Koek, Manhasset HS
Tristan Yang, Jericho HS

Swimming, girls

Samantha Anderson, Manhasset HS
Meghan Brady, Sayville HS
Victoria Wang, Manhasset HS

Tennis, girls

Stephanie Marcheret, Syosset HS

Volleyball, boys

Tyler Bottcher, Eastport-South Manor HS
Matthew Fitzgerald, Plainview-Old Bethpage JFK HS
Niall Haughney, Bay Shore HS
Colin O’Connor, Connetquot HS
Arkaidiy Rivkin, Syosset HS
Jack Stanley, Massapequa HS
Zach Thomas, West Islip HS
Peter Zhang, Great Neck South HS

Volleyball, girls

Savanna Appleton, Massapequa HS
Maeve Britt, South Side HS
Angela Bush, Kellenberg HS
Dylan Katz, Plainview-Old Bethpage JFK HS
Emily Layton, Plainview-Old Bethpage JFK HS
Taylor Marsh, Smithtown West HS
Keira Mullaney, South Side HS
Giuliana Pamatat, Garden City HS
Alexandra Patsos, Connetquot HS
Morgan Wolcott, Half Hollow Hills West HS

Wrestling, boys

Dunia Sibomana-Rodriguez, Long Beach HS
Rocco DeStefano, East Islip HS
Devin Downes, Plainedge HS
Will Russell, Manhasset HS
Anthony Severino, Lindenhurst HS

Wrestling, girls

Reese Adams, Calhoun HS
Haley Gonzales, Hicksville HS
Naomi Gonzalez, Valley Stream North HS
Gabrielle Severin, Bethpage HS