Gerard 'Jerry' Sussingham, former Blue Cross director and gifted craftsman from Baldwin, dies at 97

Gerard Sussingham used his woodworking skills to make gifts for others. Credit: Sussingham family
Gerard James "Jerry" Sussingham could do just about anything with his hands. He handled the plumbing and wiring in his family’s home, cut down trees with a handsaw and carved their wood into sculptures, some 7 feet tall.
"He was kind of like a Renaissance man in some ways," said his son Robert Sussingham, of Merrick, recalling his father’s lifelong appetite for learning.
Jerry Sussingham, a longtime Baldwin resident who rose from messenger to director of hospital claims during 44 years at Blue Cross, died of natural causes on Nov. 9 at home. He was 97.
From humble beginnings
Born March 25, 1929, in the Bronx, Sussingham was 3 when his father died and his mother was hospitalized. His grandparents, George and Mary Schroff, took in all five siblings rather than separate the children during the Great Depression.
Money was scarce and the family made do. He and his brother slept under several blankets in an unheated room, Robert Sussingham recalled. His grandfather repeatedly sharpened worn hedge clippers, so Jerry bought him a new pair with his first paycheck, said his daughter Elaine Sussingham, of Santa Rosa, California.
"He just had a lot of gratitude for how he grew up," she said.
As a teenager, he worked in a bicycle shop and delivered buttons and sewing supplies through Manhattan’s Garment District. Rather than simply drop off packages, he asked questions about the businesses he visited, Robert Sussingham recalled.
At 20, he joined Blue Cross as a messenger. The messengers wore smocks, but he noticed that company leaders wore suits. Before delivering correspondence, he removed his smock to reveal a suit underneath, his son Chris Sussingham, of Lakeland, Florida, said.
He also regularly stopped at employees’ desks to ask about their work. "He’s forever inquisitive," Elaine said.
Jerry Sussingham eventually rose to director of hospital claims. In the early 1970s, he joined a team of employees computerizing claims processed through handwritten records and punch cards. He took computer courses and spent five years helping computerize the claims department alongside his regular job, often working nights and weekends. He later presented the work to Blue Cross leaders in other cities, Elaine said.
Chris said his father never attended college or sought acclaim, yet built a life around family and helping others.
"Dad did not live for victory and power, but for honesty and grace," he said.
A craftsman's touch
Decades after his grandparents had kept his family together, Sussingham made room for his father-in-law when he could no longer stay in a nursing home.
"No, he can stay here with us. He’ll always have a home," Chris recalled his father saying. He had help with the foundation and framing but finished the two-room addition himself, working nights and weekends on the wiring and Sheetrock.
Sussingham also put his woodworking skills to use making gifts for others. About 25 years ago, he built a dollhouse complete with miniature fireplaces and handmade furniture for the young daughters of family friend Michelle Sheehan Prior, of Rockville Centre. Her girls, 6 and 3, were enchanted.
"He figured that they would be delighted and created it as a labor of love," Prior said.
Daniel O’Connor, their next-door neighbor for nearly 38 years, recalled afternoons golfing with Sussingham and long conversations with him and his wife, Peggy, in the couple’s living room.
"Every conversation I’ve had with him was met with an easy smile, humility, kindness, respect and warmth," O’Connor, of Baldwin, said.
A lifetime together
Sussingham remembered the moment Margaret "Peggy" Waldron looked up and smiled at him on University Avenue in the Bronx, a moment that made his heart melt, his family said. They wed in 1952, beginning a marriage that lasted 70 years. Decades later, he carved a wooden sculpture of the couple, depicting Peggy in the same long dress and hairstyle she wore on their first date.
After Peggy died, he kept her funeral prayer card beneath his pillow.
"She’s never left me from the time she passed. She’s always been with me," Elaine said he told her. When Sussingham died, he held the card in one hand while Elaine held the other.
He is survived by his sons and their spouses, Robert and Kathy; Thomas and Marie, of Merrick; Chris and Robin; and John and Helen, of The Villages, Florida; his daughter, Elaine, and her husband, Jeff Brown; seven grandchildren; and three great-grandchildren.
Sussingham was cremated. A celebration of life is planned for the spring on Long Island.
Loading video…
Navy honor for LI hero killed in Vietnam ... Newsday's holiday movie preview ... Acid attack suspect seeks release ... Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies
Loading video…
Navy honor for LI hero killed in Vietnam ... Newsday's holiday movie preview ... Acid attack suspect seeks release ... Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies



