Mary Wagner, former Wantagh teacher and longtime community leader, dies at 85

Mary Wagner organized an annual history essay contest for Wantagh students through the Jerusalem Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution. Credit: Wagner family
Mary Wagner was the mother who baked brownies for her sons’ school trips and brought sliced oranges to their soccer games. Many of their friends grew up treating the Wagners’ Wantagh home as their own — and Mary as a second mother.
"When she asked somebody, ‘How are you?’ she really wanted to know," said her son Peter Wagner, of Suffolk County. "It wasn’t just a pleasantry for her."
Mary Wagner, a former teacher who spent decades supporting Wantagh schools, the public library and local history organizations, died Nov. 2 after a battle with Alzheimer’s disease. She was 85.
Leading by example
Born March 26, 1941, Mary Wagner, the daughter of Franklin and Lillian Dexter, grew up in Baldwin. Her father was school board president, and her mother was active in the PTA. Community service "was part of her blood, really," Peter Wagner said.
A Colby College graduate with a master’s in education from SUNY New Paltz, Wagner taught first grade in the Sachem Central School District. She and her husband, Wayne Wagner, settled in Wantagh in 1967 and raised sons Peter and David. After taking time away to raise them, she returned as a substitute teacher at Wantagh Middle School in the 1980s.
At Wantagh Elementary School, Wagner became involved in the PTA, eventually serving as co-president. Alison Cook-Lorch, of Bellmore, who attended school with Peter, remembered Wagner as "a staple at the elementary school, best class mom."
Preserving the past
In 1998, Wagner joined the Jerusalem Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution. She took pride in tracing her ancestry back to England and researching her family’s Revolutionary War connections, Peter Wagner recalled.
She served as chapter chaplain, treasurer and vice regent, but the chapter’s history essay contest was the project she talked about most at home, her son said. For years, she organized the contest, reading Wantagh students’ essays and selecting the winners, who received awards and read their work aloud at annual ceremonies at the Wantagh Public Library.
"She was so proud of doing that," her son said. "She loved working with the young students."
Wagner's interest in the hamlet's history also drew her to the Wantagh Preservation Society, where she and her husband served as trustees. As membership chair, she organized membership renewals and encouraged residents to join. Cook-Lorch recalled the couple attending events regularly, "ready to offer a helping hand or a kind word."
The couple also served as co-presidents of the Friends of the Wantagh Public Library. In 2016, she was among seven women recognized at the "Women of Wantagh" celebration for their community contributions.
A love passed down
Mary and Wayne Wagner shared that love of history with their children. Family vacations included national parks, museums and historic sites. When their son David Wagner, of Manhattan, finally persuaded them to visit Cancun, Mexico, a day trip to Mayan ruins still made the itinerary, he recalled. Peter Wagner later majored in history, an interest he traced to those trips. "It stems from that, from their love of history," he said.
Mary Dexter and Wayne Wagner met in eighth grade band, where she played violin and he played drums. Their friendship grew into a high school romance, sustained by letters while they attended different colleges. "We loved to dance together, we sang together, we loved music," Wayne Wagner, of Nassau County, recalled. "We were really good partners." The pair married in June 1963 and kept dancing throughout their 63-year marriage.
On weekends, they hunted for Depression-era glassware at garage sales, reselling their finds. David Wagner even designed business cards for their venture, which he christened "Depression Obsession."
Mary Wagner continued her mother’s tradition of calling family members who lived far away whenever the moon was full. She called her children and grandchildren, and as her grandchildren grew older, they began calling her. What she loved, son David recalled, was that "they were all looking under the same moon."
She is survived by her husband, Wayne Wagner, of Nassau County; sons Peter Wagner, of Suffolk County, and his wife, Sandra Wagner, and David Wagner, of Manhattan, and his wife, Lacy O’Toole; brother Richard Dexter; and five grandchildren. She was predeceased by her brother, Thomas Dexter.
A wake was Nov. 6 at the Wantagh Abbey funeral home. A celebration of life followed on Nov. 7, with burial at Pinelawn Memorial Park.
One town's budget about-face ... See the highest paid educators on LI ... What's in store with the weather ... Out East: Bedell Cellar
One town's budget about-face ... See the highest paid educators on LI ... What's in store with the weather ... Out East: Bedell Cellar



