Sands Point Preserve in January 2025, in Sands Point. The...

Sands Point Preserve in January 2025, in Sands Point. The facility's cesspools are deemed illegal by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

The federal government has reached a settlement with Nassau County to shut down 14 large cesspools that could contaminate drinking water.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency said in a legal filing Tuesday that the cesspools — which release wastewater from county park bathrooms, visitors centers and recreational facilities into the soil underground — are located above the aquifer, which supplies Long Island's drinking water.

The government alleges that Nassau County, its Parks Department and its Public Works Department violated the 1974 Safe Drinking Water Act and a 2005 mandate to close such cesspools.

"Unsanitary waste from [large capacity cesspools] poses a serious risk to public health because it can enter ground water and contaminate drinking water sources," the government wrote.

County officials agreed to pay $100,000 to the EPA, court records show, and adhere to a number of deadlines to shut down the cesspools lining Nassau's North Shore. A cesspool beneath the Bailey Arboretum in Locust Valley, for instance, must be inoperable by July 2028. At least one cesspool located at the Muttontown Preserve was set to close this week, records show.

If Nassau does not abide by its deadlines and reporting mandates, it faces penalties of up to $750 per violation per day. After 60 days of non-compliance, those penalties jump to $2,000 per day.

"We’ve reached an agreement that will deliver on environmental protections for Nassau County residents," he wrote, adding that the agency looked forward to "continuing our close relationship with the County as they close these cesspools to prevent the spread of contamination."

In a statement to Newsday, Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman wrote that the county "continues to work with our partners at the EPA to update septic systems at our acquired properties. These updates are an environmental victory for Nassau County that improves our infrastructure and benefits the health and safety of our taxpayers."

The EPA's legal filing and settlement followed a yearslong effort by the federal agency and predating Blakeman's tenure to decommission Nassau's large cesspools. 

Five of the cesspools named by the government are located in the Muttontown Preserve, with two beneath Nassau Hall and two under Chelsea Mansion. The small Village of Muttontown is among Long Island’s wealthiest enclaves, with the median household income reaching nearly a quarter-million dollars, Newsday has reported. The village mayor could not immediately be reached.

Four other cesspools named in the lawsuit are located in the Sands Point Preserve, with one at the children’s learning center and another at the historic Hempstead House. Nassau lawmakers representing the Sands Point and Muttontown Preserves could not immediately be reached Wednesday.

 Among many environmental issues ranging from flooding roads to storm damage, residents say contaminated drinking water poses the greatest risk to Long Island over the next 10 years, according to a recent Newsday/Siena poll.

In Suffolk, officials have been working for years to replace every polluting septic tank and cesspool across the county. 

Adrienne Esposito, executive director of the Citizens Campaign for the Environment, said Wednesday that the situation in Nassau was "terrible," noting "100% of Long Island’s drinking water comes from underground."

"Every septic and cesspool is leaching into our drinking water system and drains into the marine environment. It’s a double whammy," she told Newsday. "The septics and cesspools pollute drinking water, and also our bays and harbors and estuaries."

MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Highest paid educators on LI ... Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'

MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Highest paid educators on LI ... Out East: Bedell Cellars Credit: Newsday

LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME