A week after the election, remnants of Long Island's midterm...

A week after the election, remnants of Long Island's midterm cycle had been spotted throughout Nassau and Suffolk counties.  Credit: Newsday

There’s a dismal time on Long Island after Halloween decorations come down and before neighborhoods are fully dressed in Christmas lights: the season of forgotten political campaign signs.

From tree-lined residential blocks in Floral Park to beach paths in Amagansett, candidates’ leftover signs for local, state and federal offices from both major political parties lay forgotten among the fall leaves. For politically exhausted Long Islanders over the hump of Nov. 3 and looking to steer clear of politics at the Thanksgiving dinner table, lingering campaign signs may not evoke affectionate memories of this year's candidates.

Local residents have now raised an obvious question: Who will clean them up?

"It’s everywhere you look ... It’s every road, every neighborhood, everywhere you drive on Long Island. It’s taking over every bare spot," Laurie Lynn-Claps, 62, of Greenvale, told Newsday by phone. "It’s going to be like this for what seems like forever."

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • After elections on Long Island, campaign signs from both major political parties often remain neglected, raising questions about responsibility for their removal.
  • Local party volunteers are involved in sign removal, but enforcement of rules regarding sign duration varies, with some local governments lacking the means to enforce them effectively.
  • Some candidates have taken steps to personally remove the signs following the election. 

Who's in charge?

The answer to the question of whose job it is to clean up signs varies.

Representatives from Long Island’s Republican and Democratic parties told Newsday there was no standard practice for who rounds up the signs after an election, and that it usually fell on candidate's campaigns and party volunteers.

It’s everywhere you look ... It’s every road, every neighborhood, everywhere you drive on Long Island. It’s taking over every bare spot. 

— Laurie Lynn-Claps, 62, Greenvale resident

Democrats and Republicans routinely accuse their opponents of stealing their signs before Election Day. Jay Jacobs, the New York State and Nassau Democratic Party chair, said he would raise the issue of sign cleanup at a party meeting on Monday. "If you put them out, you should pick them up," he said.

Suffolk Republican Party chair Jesse Garcia told Newsday he was coordinating a group of party volunteers to drive around and pick up signs.

"We have a bunch of volunteers who put them up and who go around and take them down," he said. The cleanup would likely be completed this weekend, he said. But, "we don't touch the Democratic signs."

The Department of Public Works also takes away  signs from the 2,000 miles of county roads spanning Suffolk, county spokesman Mike Martino said. Those workers also collect signs even before Election Day that don't have a proper permit, he said. A spokesman for Nassau did not respond to questions about countywide post-election cleanup efforts.

Some local governments have rules about how many days signs can stay up following Election Day, but it appears they have little means to enforce them.

In North Hempstead, for instance, there are no rules about small campaign signs in public grassy medians. Town spokesman Umberto Mignardi said town attorneys can't enforce political signs the same way they can't enforce someone advertising a soccer camp; the law has to be applied equally. But as a practice, town officials call various campaigns to come collect their materials, and the Highway Department picks them up as well. 

In New York City, it is illegal to post signs on public property. Residents can file complaints online and the sanitation department will remove the postings. Fines for violating the rules can hit up to $250 for repeat offenders. 

But for Lynn-Claps of Greenvale, the signs raise a more existential question. While they help with name recognition for candidates, they don't tell voters anything about the candidates' platforms, she said. 

"It ends up feeling like more of a popularity contest," she said. "What do the signs do? How do they help us? They’re just making a mess."

Visible campaign signs are popular because they're one of the most effective ways to increase name recognition among voters, according to 2013 and 2015 studies out of Vanderbilt and Columbia universities.

Probably the most painful part is [candidates] with no connection to the community being so quick to put up signs and then failing to pick them up.

— Sergio Argueta, 48, Long Beach resident 

Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, who mounted a failed bid for governor, spent nearly a half-million dollars on lawn signs statewide this year, according to state campaign finance records. Gov. Kathy Hochul, in contrast, spent about $47,000 in 2022.

Democrat Joe Scianablo, who secured a historic victory beating Hempstead Town Supervisor John Ferretti, spent about $2,000 on lawn signs this year, according to campaign data. Ferretti, though he had signs displayed in various neighborhoods, did not disclose any lawn sign expenses in campaign reports.

For Sergio Argueta, a Long Beach resident who's an assistant principal in Hempstead, candidates who abandon their campaign signs show just how little they care about certain neighborhoods.

"Probably the most painful part is [candidates] with no connection to the community being so quick to put up signs and then failing to pick them up," Argueta, 48, told Newsday. "They’re so quick to come and promote themselves. It’s almost disrespectful when they don’t come and clean up our community afterward."

Doing their part

In the days following the Nov. 3 election, several candidates posted on social media about their cleanup plans.

Nassau Legis. Olena Nicks (D-Uniondale) posted a selfie carrying handfuls of her own signs. "Doing my part to keep the district clean, I hope the others follow suit. If you hosted a lawn sign on your lawn, I’ll be glad to pick it up," she wrote.

Legis. Scott Davis (D-Rockville Centre) and Anthony Capone, a Republican candidate who lost his bid for Nassau legislator, posted similar messages.

On South Broadway between Murray Road and Mineola Avenue in Hicksville, dozens of signs just inches apart lined the grassy median last week. Kubir, a BP gas station attendant who declined to give his last name, said cleanup speed has varied. "Sometimes after an election they pick them up right away," he said.

This week, they were gone. 

Working Moms: Finding your 'village' ... Out East: Bedell Cellars ... HS plays of the week Credit: Newsday

One town's budget about-face ... See the highest paid educators on LI ... What's in store with the weather ... Out East: Bedell Cellar

Working Moms: Finding your 'village' ... Out East: Bedell Cellars ... HS plays of the week Credit: Newsday

One town's budget about-face ... See the highest paid educators on LI ... What's in store with the weather ... Out East: Bedell Cellar

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME