Babylon Town board approves budget with a nearly 6% tax hike, overriding residents' concerns

Kristin Schuster, of Deer Park, addresses Babylon Town Council members at Wednesday afternoon's budget hearing. Credit: Thomas Hengge
The Babylon Town Board has approved a budget with a nearly 6% tax hike, despite continued complaints from residents that such tax increases may drive them out of the town.
The board voted unanimously Wednesday afternoon to green-light the $218.3 million spending plan for next year. The tax levy will increase nearly 5.8% from $148.3 million in this year’s budget to $156.9 million for 2027. The average resident not living in a village will see a $113 annual increase in taxes.
Town officials said $75 of that $113 is due to increased costs for health insurance and pension payouts, as well as salary increases for contracted union employees.
After facing fierce criticism from residents over a proposed 29% — or $36,320 — increase in his salary in the new budget, Supervisor Rich Schaffer last week announced to Newsday that he would forgo forego the raise and instead take a pay cut from $123,680 to $120,000.
The town also removed salary increases for other elected officials that had been included in the budget, including a 13.3% raise for Tax Receiver Jennifer Montiglio and a 9.7% bump for Town Clerk Janina Martinez, which would have brought both of their pay to $140,000. The original proposed budget also included a 4.8% increase for the four town council members to a collective $315,000 salary.
Those savings did little to chip away at the tax levy increase, however, and the town’s new budget busts the state’s 2% tax cap. In response to public reproach for piercing the tax cap for the fourth time in five years, the town has promised the budgets for 2028 and 2029 will stay under the cap.
Prior to the board vote on Wednesday, just over a half dozen residents expressed their frustration with the tax hike, saying yearly increases may force them to live elsewhere.
"Why not look at reducing nonessential spending, improve efficiency, spending reduction taken from reserves and seek alternative revenue," Deer Park resident Sherry Levinson said. "We want to stay in Deer Park so we are trying to keep ourselves in our homes by living within our means. We would like you to find additional savings by carefully and thoughtfully reviewing line by line the expenses."
Many also criticized the budget process, with several residents asking the town to move such meetings to the evening and to have a forum that would allow residents to have specific budget questions answered.
"I think that the town needs to be more responsive to your constituents," Elise Antonelli, of Babylon, told the board, adding a request that the town create an advisory board where residents can "give you our input and actually have a dialogue with you."
Asked by Newsday after the meeting whether the process might change next year, town officials said they would consider adjustments.
"We've heard the requests for evening meetings and budget workshops, and that feedback is part of how we'll look at the way we conduct business going forward," town spokesman Ryan Bonner said in a statement. "Every Town Board meeting is streamed live on YouTube, and anyone who can't attend in person can submit comments online and get a response."
Antonelli told Newsday after the meeting that she had sent budget questions to the town but the answers were unsatisfactory. Seeking information on the costs involved for one program, Antonelli said she asked about how the town was projecting expenses.
"They responded by explaining the activities performed but did not attribute dollar amounts, which was the whole point of the question," she said.
After the public comment period, the board voted 5-0 to approve the budget as one resident shouted, "We oppose this!" and another chided, "Go back to school and learn what a budget is!"
LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'
LI town will have leaner budget ... MTA projects future $1B budget deficit ... Oheka Castle sale finalized ... Working Moms: Finding your 'village'
