East Hampton's vacation rental market generated $100 million, new report says

A couple and their dog walk along Main Street in East Hampton on Tuesday. Credit: Elizabeth Sagarin
East Hampton Town’s vacation rental market generates roughly $100 million annually, and hundreds of properties are potentially violating short-term rental laws, officials said, citing data from a town consultant.
Of the 1,117 properties in the town advertised online, 885 were suspected of violating at least one portion of East Hampton's short-term rental laws, according to the data, which was presented by Councilwoman Cate Rogers during a work session on Tuesday. Those violations include missing or invalid rental registry numbers and advertisements listing more guests than the town allowed for the property, she said.
The figures represent potential violations flagged through online listings, not confirmed code violations.
Data was compiled using Rentalscape, an AI-powered service that analyzes online advertisements and listings on sites like Airbnb and Vrbo.
The board contracted to use Rentalscape in May after Rogers proposed a crackdown on illegal short-term rentals, which she has said diminishes housing stock for full-time residents and hurts local hotels.
"I think that this industry is taking advantage of this town, and I think that's something we have to look at," Rogers said.
During the summer peak, the town had approximately 2,442 licensed short-term rental properties, Rogers said. Properties must register and pay a $200 fee for a town license, which lasts two years.
East Hampton is a seasonal tourist destination, and residents complain about noise, garbage and other issues coming from visitors to their neighborhoods, officials said.
Rogers described short-term rentals as businesses “that work in our neighborhoods — and not in our commercial districts.” Rentalscape’s data showed the industry generated an estimated $99.5 million over the last year, which officials said did not include unlisted properties.
Adding accountability
East Hampton homeowners cannot rent out their homes more than 14 days in a six-month period, and are limited to two transactions during that time frame. Rentalscape identified at least 447 properties that appeared to have exceeded that rule, Rogers said. She added that rental platforms are not required to ensure that advertisements comply with the town's registration requirements.
“We have nothing in our code right now that holds them accountable,” Rogers said.
The report comes as Southold Town — which also uses Rentalscape — looks to reduce its short-term rental stock by roughly 80%, Newsday previously reported.
Rogers presented social media posts that suggest out-of-town investors are buying up homes in the Hamptons and using them as vacation rental businesses. She said town data showed 61% of licensed rentals had owners with addresses outside of East Hampton Town.
That is opposed to full-time residents who, officials said, occasionally rent to supplement their income.
The presentation also highlighted the growing role of professional rental managers. The highest-earning host was a New York City company managing more than 250 listings in the community. The firm made more than $7 million over the past year, said Rogers, who redacted the names of homeowners and rental managers in her presentation.
Balancing act
Next month, Rogers plans to present research on short-term rentals' effects on housing affordability, water resources and traffic, along with examples of regulations adopted elsewhere. Her goal, she has said, is to propose updates to the town’s decade-old rental code to address short-term rental issues.
Councilman Ian Calder-Piedmonte questioned what additional regulations would accomplish without better enforcement. He said Rentalscape should be used to “target abuse” of the town’s laws.
“I do think it’s an enforcement issue,” he said. “This is a useful tool, and it shows that we have many violations."
Rogers said the town had drafted compliance letters addressing missing registration numbers and over-occupancy. She said she is consulting with the town attorney about possible next steps, adding it’s “very difficult” to police rental violations through traditional code enforcement methods.
Councilman Tom Flight urged the board to consider the industry's economic benefits. He said he would be open to imposing a tax on these properties to offset the cost of short-term rentals, including sanitation and enforcement demands.
“It is more than $100 million. There's also ancillary jobs that relate to this: the cleaners, the property managers who kind of work within this industry,” Flight said. “I think one has to be careful that as you look to regulate it, that we're taking into account those overall local economic issues.”
Rental review
- East Hampton Town’s vacation rental market generates roughly $100 million annually, according to data compiled through online advertisements and listings.
- Of the 1,117 properties in the town advertised online, 885 were suspected of violating at least one portion of the town's short-term rental laws.
- The board contracted to use the AI-powered service Rentalscape in May after Councilwoman Cate Rogers proposed a crackdown on illegal short-term rentals.
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game
