Oheka Castle in Huntington was sold at auction last month...

Oheka Castle in Huntington was sold at auction last month for $72 million. Credit: Newsday/J. Conrad Williams Jr.

A Woodbury investment firm is asking a federal bankruptcy judge to set aside $3 million it claims it is owed by the outgoing corporate owner of Oheka Castle from the $72 million sale of the Huntington mansion and hospitality emporium.

Tabone LLC and its managing partner, John M. Tabone, in a lawsuit filed Nov. 9 in U.S. Bankruptcy Court, say castle owner Kahn Property Owner LLC and Oheka operator Gary Melius refused to pay the company last year for consulting services aimed at helping Melius dig himself out of more than $60 million in debt before putting the mansion up for auction last month. Melius has an ownership stake in Kahn Property Owner LLC.

The lawsuit was filed as Melius nears completion of a deal to sell the castle, its catering and hotel operations and condominium development rights on the property to Gold Coast Property & Estate Management LLC, which submitted the tentative winning bid of $72 million.

The parties are scheduled to meet at a hearing at 2 p.m. Tuesday in bankruptcy court in Central Islip to confirm Gold Coast Property & Estate Management's $7.2 million down payment on the castle. It wasn't immediately clear whether the Tabone LLC lawsuit would block the sale of Oheka to Gold Coast.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • Woodbury investment firm Tabone LLC filed a lawsuit in federal bankruptcy court seeking $3 million it says it is owed by the outgoing owner of Oheka Castle in Huntington.
  • Tabone LLC says Kahn Property Owner LLC and Gary Melius reneged on the payment after Tabone had sought to help Melius pay off about $60 million in debt. Melius' lawyer objected to Tabone's claim.
  • The lawsuit claims Melius had rejected Tabone's proposal to partner with a major hotel chain such as Four Seasons Hotels & Resorts, which wanted to rebrand the Huntington landmark as "Four Seasons at Oheka Castle."

In a deposition filed with the lawsuit, John Tabone said his relationship with Melius dated to a Jan. 27, 2024, brunch meeting, when Melius asked for his help to pay off his debts.

Melius hired Tabone LLC in early 2024 to help raise between $50 million to $100 million to refinance the Oheka debt, the lawsuit says.

Melius dropped Tabone in May 2025 and began talks with another company, Taconic Capital, Tabone said in the deposition.

"We have a deal and then we don't have one," Melius said that May, according to Tabone's five-page deposition. "If I do my deal with Taconic, you get nothing."

Taconic Capital, aka 135 W. Gate Drive, subsequently refinanced Melius' $60 million debt, Newsday has previously reported.

'Four Seasons' rebrand nixed

Tabone said in his deposition that he had proposed several financing plans for Oheka, including securing "branded residence partners" such as a major hotel chain.

He said in court papers that Melius had declined to partner with Four Seasons Hotels & Resorts, which wanted naming rights at the century-old castle. The chain wanted to partner with Melius and rebrand the mansion as "Four Seasons at Oheka Castle," Tabone said.

Melius objected to the proposal because he "did not want any partners," Tabone said.

Oheka operator Gary Melius at the castle last month.

Oheka operator Gary Melius at the castle last month. Credit: Newsday/Alejandra Villa Loarca

Four Seasons did not respond to an email seeking comment.

In court papers, Tabone LLC says Melius agreed to pay the firm a $3 million consulting fee regardless of whether the company completed the refinancing. But, the lawsuit says, Melius later refused to pay after withdrawing from the deal.

In the lawsuit, Tabone's lawyer says legal precedents make it "clear that a party cannot refuse to close and then contend because no closing occurred, it has no liability."

Melius, the lawsuit says, "should not be allowed to disclaim [his] contractual obligations when [Tabone LLC] successfully completed the project for which it was retained."

Melius lawyer's objections

In an email, Melius' lawyer, Joseph Maniscalco, of Wantagh, objected to Tabone's claim.

"We have read the opposition of Tabone and disagree with the analysis, the legal implications of his argument or the affidavit," Maniscalco wrote last Tuesday. "The Debtor [Kahn Property Owner] intends to defend its position to disallow the claim and allow the Court to make a decision." 

John Tabone did not respond to messages seeking comment.

Lawyers for Tabone LLC and Gold Coast Property & Estate Management did not return messages seeking comment.

Gold Coast, the winning bidder at the Oct. 27 auction, is run by principals Ronald Browning and Paul Alflen. The company outbid six other entities, auction officials said.

Kahn Property Owner LLC filed for federal Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection last year to hold off a foreclosure sale. Melius, who lives at the castle, said at the time the castle had been in foreclosure for a decade.

Court documents show Melius, 82, owes about $60 million to 135 W. Gate Drive, and between $8 million and $10 million to unsecured creditors and for professional fees.

Melius has said the auction sale price is sufficient to retire his debts.

What's in store with the weather ... The hottest gifts for 2026 ... AI giving young basketball players a boost Credit: Newsday

October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather

What's in store with the weather ... The hottest gifts for 2026 ... AI giving young basketball players a boost Credit: Newsday

October's LI home prices are out ... LIRR's Thanksgiving expanded service ... Suffolk police vehicle auction ... What's in store with the weather

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME