Southold town police want to replace this police boat with...

Southold town police want to replace this police boat with a FEMA grant, but the award links funding to restrictions on DEI policies and cooperation with immigration enforcement. Credit: Elizabeth Sagarin

More than $2 million in grants to two East End communities are in limbo after officials there raised concern that funding terms were tied to immigration enforcement and diversity, equity and inclusion policies.

In early October, the Southold town board voted to authorize the supervisor to sign contracts for three federal grants that would pay for new police vehicles, radios and a marine patrol boat. Officials have yet to sign the contracts after discovering "problematic" terms, according to Town Attorney Ben Johnson.

In the agreements, the federal government is trying to impose conditions on grant funding that require recipients to cooperate with federal deportation efforts and reject DEI policies.

Southold's review comes weeks after Southampton Village rescinded a Federal Emergency Management Agency grant for firefighters' equipment over what village officials called "unacceptable" contract language. Southold Town is awaiting guidance from the state attorney general’s office before signing the agreements, Johnson said in an interview. 

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • Southold Town is taking a closer look at the fine print of federal grant awards, citing concerns about conditions related to federal immigration efforts and diversity, equity and inclusion policies.
  • Southampton Village rescinded acceptance of a FEMA grant after raising similar concerns about contract language.
  • Earlier this month, a federal judge in Rhode Island ruled that the federal government violated a permanent injunction by attaching immigration-related conditions to FEMA grants.

Johnson said the town doesn’t want to give up the funding or risk future litigation.

"We’ve been put in somewhat of a difficult position by the federal government," he said Wednesday.

The East End municipalities are tangled in a broader national debate over the fine print in federal contracts that require local governments to comply with immigration enforcement.

New York is a plaintiff in a lawsuit with 20 other states challenging what they contend are unlawful conditions tied to federal grants appropriated by Congress.

On Nov. 9, a federal judge in Rhode Island struck down immigration-related requirements, calling them "unduly coercive." The decision enjoins the federal government from enforcing those restrictions.

"The courts have determined that this is too coercive," Johnson said in an interview. "We don’t want to accept any money that’s contrary to the values of Southold as a whole, so we’re being very careful as to do our homework and not just blindly accept money with strings attached."

In a statement, a FEMA spokesperson told Newsday: "The federal judge in Rhode Island’s ruling is yet another attempt to obstruct President Trump’s agenda and the will of the American people. Emergency preparedness funds come with clear requirements and DHS and FEMA remain committed to ensuring that federal grant programs are administered in a manner that aligns with national security priorities and federal law."

Risking needed upgrades

The town is considering three contracts: One is an award from FEMA and two are from the U.S. Department of Justice. Newsday obtained a copy of the agreements from the town under the state's Freedom of Information Law.

A proposed $536,585 FEMA port-security grant for a new police boat references both immigration and DEI programs, according to a copy of the contract. 

Under the agreement, municipalities receiving funding must honor immigration detainer requests, share information and "not prohibit voluntary cooperation with" the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. They also must not "leak or otherwise publicize" immigration enforcement actions. Town officials said the requirements may conflict with the state's Local Cops, Local Crimes Act banning local law enforcement agencies from entering into cooperation agreements with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

FEMA document

A federal grant contract between FEMA and Southold prohibits "restrictions on information sharing by state and local government entities with DHS regarding the citizenship or immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual."

The conditions also say that recipients "do not, and will not during the term of this financial assistance award, operate any programs that advance or promote DEI." The award may be canceled if recipients violate the terms, the contract language states.

Two other grants contain similar references, according to the documents. That funding covers $132,857 for radio upgrades through the Community Oriented Policing Services, and $871,701 for new vehicles under the Byrne Discretionary Community Project grant program.

Southold Police Chief Steven Grattan said he’s concerned about risking much-needed funding, but that it’s important to make sure the language is thoroughly vetted.

The department, Grattan said, hopes to use a portion of the grant to replace an aging "pleasure craft" used to patrol Long Island Sound and Fishers Island. The town would swap out the 22-year-old watercraft for a SAFE boat, a vessel outfitted for law enforcement.

"It’s a big help to receive that money so that the local taxpayers aren’t footing the bill," Grattan said in an interview.

"We’re regularly responding to emergencies on the water and marine-related incidents, so just having a boat that’s reliable to get our harbormasters and officers out to provide assistance is critical for our operations."

FEMA document

A federal grant contract between FEMA and Southold states the town may not "operate any programs that advance or promote DEI, DEIA, or discriminatory equity ideology in violation of Federal anti-discrimination laws."

In October, Southampton Village trustees voted to accept a $560,000 FEMA award for new fire department radios. But two weeks later, the board rescinded its approval. Trustee Robert Coburn said Thursday the village is concerned about the immigration and DEI-related provisions.

In both Southold Town and Southampton Village, officials said they secured extensions through mid-December to sign the grant awards and are awaiting next steps.

The condition of the fire department’s radios is "not an abject safety risk right now," he said. The village may turn to a surplus fund to buy them if the grant wording isn't modified.

Pressure to hold off

Asked if he favored the grant requirements, Rep. Nick LaLota (R-Amityville) said in an email: "I support requiring recipients of federal taxpayer dollars to comply with longstanding federal law, including bipartisan immigration information-sharing laws signed by President Clinton. I’m committed to helping Long Island municipalities receive the federal funding I’ve secured."

The Southold Police Department has said it does not enforce immigration laws, a common practice for town police departments concerned that working with federal officers could undermine public trust or deter crime victims from seeking help because of their status.

Councilman Brian Mealy said Southold isn’t alone in this predicament and described the terms of the agreement as "diabolical" at a town meeting on Tuesday.

"I don’t want to be bullied by any kind of federal agency," Mealy said. 

The Nov. 9 ruling from Rhode Island U.S. District Judge Mary S. McElroy said the government violated a permanent injunction prohibiting immigration-related conditions. She characterized the terms in her ruling as "unduly coercive" and "unlawfully ambiguous," according to court documents.

In July, LaLota presented a supersized check totaling $1 million to Southold officials at a press conference, weeks after he said he would not support funding requests from municipalities that blocked cooperation with ICE.

Several Southold residents have raised concerns over the proposed terms. In August, the town board approved a response plan to ICE activity that includes dispatching police officers to de-escalate potential confrontations.

Some say the terms of the funding contradict the new town policies

"I felt like those would be undermined," Sandra Benedetto, of Greenport, said in an interview. Benedetto, a former chair of the Southold Democratic Committee, said the town should not enter into an agreement "that would betray our principles."

Newsday's Alek Lewis contributed to this story.

Loading video…

Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies ... Newsday's holiday movie preview ... Have a historic Thanksgiving dinner Credit: Newsday

Navy honor for LI hero killed in Vietnam ... Newsday's holiday movie preview ... Acid attack suspect seeks release ... Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies

Loading video…

Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies ... Newsday's holiday movie preview ... Have a historic Thanksgiving dinner Credit: Newsday

Navy honor for LI hero killed in Vietnam ... Newsday's holiday movie preview ... Acid attack suspect seeks release ... Trendy Bites: Rainbow chocolate chip cookies

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME