One party ally said that for Hempstead Town Supervisor-elect Joe...

One party ally said that for Hempstead Town Supervisor-elect Joe Scianablo to succeed, he will need to be "very blunt" in dealing with the town's payroll and other issues. Credit: Newsday / Howard Schnapp

The well-oiled GOP machine in the big Town of Hempstead took on damage at the polls.

Democrat Joe Scianablo's win as town supervisor marked the most substantial "flip" of the election season on Long Island. Not only is the 49-year-old political newcomer, Marine veteran and former NYPD police officer preparing to steer America's most populated township — with more than 795,700 residents — but Scianablo will occupy a potentially isolated political perch.

The town's six-member council is dominated as before by the Republican Party, placing Scianablo, the seventh vote, on an underdog's perch when he takes the oath in the New Year. The only other Democrat is Dorothy Goosby, the longest-serving member.

The suspenseful question now is what changes the voters can reasonably expect from Scianablo, who spelled out the pronunciation in an amusing Instagram message as "Sha-Knob-Low."

For those who look back, comparisons will be made to now-Rep. Laura Gillen's pathbreaking capture of the supervisorship in 2017. But the story of that race had a different drama. Gillen's rival and GOP predecessor, the late Anthony Santino, was undermined back then by intraparty attacks from town board members Bruce Blakeman and Erin King Sweeney.

Gillen won by 2,268 votes, and two years later, lost to Donald Clavin by 1,650 votes. In contrast, Scianablo unseated incumbent John Ferretti by about 10,000 votes, about the same margin by which Ferretti won the post last year for a transitional one-year term.

Far bigger turnout, including from the town's Latino and Black voters, made all the difference for Scianablo amid the national blue wave. The state's still-new even-year election law helped as Democrats intended.

Scianablo ran on taking a fresh and open approach to basic governance which meant challenging its very partisan, fiefdom-like control. Before the 2025 election, Ferretti was installed in the job by a hasty board vote under the guidance of Nassau County Republican Committee chairman Joseph Cairo.

One party ally of Scianablo said that to succeed, and not end up a one-termer like Gillen, the new winner will need to be "very blunt" in dealing with the TOH payroll, contracts, budgets and agency operations and "take a blowtorch" to the system where needed. "The Town of Hempstead is a patronage pit" that has warranted cost reform for years, the source said.

One not-so-small and conspicuous spending habit that has dogged Democrats for years is the near-constant mailing of "informational" materials and sign postings that are in effect self-promotional for Republican incumbents. The overlap between membership in local Republican clubs and committees all over TOH, and its personnel hiring and contracts, has long been too obvious to ignore.

Scianablo is expected to have one other helpful office inside town government.

Nassau Democrats this week declared Joylette Williams the winner in the town clerk race, while incumbent Kate Murray, trailing in the count, has yet to concede. Murray has long been a popular figure and was a close ally of the late ex-GOP chairman Joseph Mondello.

Resistance is expected in the GOP to Scianablo's policies. But a longtime Republican operative suggests the board could have a productive relationship if personal alienations are avoided. 

Scianablo's election night statement had just a hint of the conciliatory. "People are sending a clear message in this town that they want a government that represents them," he said. "I promise to represent everyone in the Town of Hempstead, even those who didn't vote for me."

Sounds like an old-fashioned concept. Who knows? Maybe it will work.

Columnist Dan Janison's opinions are his own.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME