U.S. air tumult is unacceptable
Travelers sleep at LaGuardia Airport on Sunday, after their flight to Dallas was canceled Friday. Credit: Newsday / James Carbone
Air travel often comes with some turbulence.
But the ongoing tumult after Friday's extraordinary nationwide ground stop, with days of cascading delays and cancellations and a lack of coherent, informative communication, is unacceptable. Our nation expects safe and reliable flights across our skies.
By Monday evening, air travel still hadn't fully recovered from the repercussions of the travel stoppage which stranded passengers, overburdened airline and aviation employees, and upended every other mode of transportation. Adding to the jitters, United Airlines experienced a short-lived, apparently unrelated "system outage" Monday.
There is still no clear, definitive explanation as to what happened Friday, why, and what federal officials are doing to make the system more reliable. Astonishingly — from President Donald Trump on down — no one in the administration has held themselves accountable. Trump, who was silent about the issue for much of the weekend, said Monday morning, "I don't take any responsibility," again pointing fingers at the Biden administration.
That no longer holds up.
The decision to ground flights was a wise one; it may be why we're talking about a massive inconvenience rather than a tragedy. But days later, what we don't know far outpaces what we do. It appears that ongoing upgrades to router systems in Arkansas and similar past work in Texas by federal contractors may have overloaded the entire system, as each attempted to connect with the network again and again, causing cascading failures. But that explanation leads to more questions.
Why would such upgrades be done on a Friday afternoon two weeks before Thanksgiving, when travel is at its busiest? Were air traffic control centers notified of the impending work? Was there risk assessment or strategic planning involved in upgrading equipment while the existing, extraordinarily vulnerable system was operating at a peak time — and, if so, did the contractor follow those plans?
As questions and concerns percolate, the lack of comprehensive, appropriate responses from the Trump administration has exacerbated the situation. When Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin took to the podium Friday evening, an anxious American public sought reassurance and information. Duffy and Mullin provided neither. As someone who began his career as a reality television star nearly 30 years ago on "The Real World: Boston," Duffy has proved unable to handle either the reality of the complex situation — or the ability to navigate it on television.
In those early hours and since, Duffy, Mullin and others have made this debacle primarily about getting an additional $50 billion in funding from Congress. But they already were allotted $12.5 billion in 2025, most of which has not been spent. Who in the federal government is keeping track of the spending for this critical infrastructure?
The new Congress must hold bipartisan hearings and provide the public with a detailed, honest accounting of what happened in this unwanted stress test of our air system — and assurances that it will find a better route forward.
MEMBERS OF THE EDITORIAL BOARD are experienced journalists who offer reasoned opinions, based on facts, to encourage informed debate about the issues facing our community.