Long Island home prices rose about 5% in October compared with the previous year. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports. Credit: Newsday/Howard Schnapp

Long Island home prices rose about 5% in October compared with the previous year, with agents saying buyer demand has remained strong through the fall so far.

But in a positive development for homebuyers, the number of for-sale listings has also increased from last October, according to data released Tuesday by OneKey MLS, a multiple listing service covering Long Island.

In Nassau County, the median price among single-family home sales climbed 4.9% year-over-year to $871,000, according to new data. That was also higher than the September median of $855,000, defying a seasonal trend in which home prices in Nassau have fallen from September to October in each of the last three years.

Better options

The median price in Suffolk County increased 4.8% in October to $733,500 compared with the same month last year. That was down from $740,000 in September.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • The median home price rose about 5% in October compared with the previous year in both Nassau and Suffolk County. 
  • The number of for-sale listings increased about 4% year over year in a positive sign for buyers.
  • Prices have continued rising on Long Island even as the national median price fell for the first time in three years last month, according to Redfin.

Buyers' options improved last month, with the number of houses on the market increasing 4.1% on Long Island to about 5,600 as of Nov. 6, according to the report.

While that’s a move in the right direction for buyers, who have faced substantial competition in the market, there are still almost half as many listings as in October 2019, according to OneKey data.

"The fact that prices continue to increase demonstrates that buyers are still very engaged in the marketplace," said Richard Haggerty, CEO of OneKey MLS. "Having more choice is benefiting buyers who’ve been hanging in there for what’s been a very challenging market.

But fewer homes sold in October than in the same month a year ago. Closed sales dropped 8.4% year-over-year in Suffolk and 1.1% in Nassau.

Long Island home sellers have fared better than others nationwide. The national median sale price fell for the first time in three years in October, data from Redfin showed, with the largest declines in Austin, Texas, Nashville, Tennessee, and Seattle.

The percentage of properties cutting their listing price on Long Island, around 10%, is about half the national average, according to Realtor.com.

"We’re not seeing the whiplash other parts of the country are seeing," Haggerty said.

Two housing markets

However, sellers experiences in the market this fall will vary, said Jared Garcia, associate broker at Weichert Realtors Performance Homes in Farmingdale.

"It’s a tale of two housing markets right now," Garcia said. "You are seeing homes [sell] under 15 days and other homes are sitting on the market substantially longer."

First-time homebuyers have seen their purchasing power diminished by rising mortgage rates, and buyers are more likely to ask sellers to make repairs or provide a seller credit that will pay for those fixes than they have been in the past few years, Garcia said.

"I think it’s going to be a grind and a struggle for these buyers," Garcia said. "We’re still going to be in a relatively strong seller’s market even if it’s softened compared to post-COVID levels," he said.

October data showed buyers are still getting little to no discount off asking prices.

The average seller in Suffolk in October got 100.3% of their list price. In Nassau, sellers received 99.2% of the original asking price, OneKey MLS data showed.

As prices have risen, more buyers are seeking family help to purchase a home, said Debra Russell, a real estate agent at Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty in Cold Spring Harbor.

Flexibility a plus

For buyers angling to get an accepted offer, flexible terms can make a difference, Russell said. That could mean offering to buy a home in an estate sale without the seller having to remove the owner’s possessions or providing flexibility in the closing date to a seller who needs to find their next home.

Russell said she has seen activity pick up over the last two weeks for her clients, including four home sellers who accepted offers from buyers this month.

"People are trying to get last-minute deals done and get into contract before the holidays hit," she said.

Mortgage rates have stabilized over the past few weeks after surging as high as 7.4% in October, according to Freddie Mac.

Rates above 7% haven’t stopped buyers from pursuing houses in the $700,000 to $900,000 range, and making offers above the asking price, said Linda Kerr, an agent at Signature Premier Properties in Sayville.

"That’s [what’s] most important in this market right now is to price it right," Kerr said. "Because if you overprice it, it will sit."

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME