Tarik Skubal at Dodger Stadium on August 21, 2026.

Tarik Skubal at Dodger Stadium on August 21, 2026. Credit: Getty Images/Harry How

The courting process has begun in earnest.

The reports began circulating during the General Manager Meetings in Las Vegas earlier this month: Two-time Cy Young award winner Tarik Skubal would be meeting with the Mets…and the Dodgers…and Blue Jays, and reportedly with the Padres this week.

This comes as no surprise. Though front-office executives have been insisting that this offseason is “business as usual,” anyone can see that the looming lockout is leading to something of an accelerated timeline. Names are coming off the board with alacrity and while a prized free agent like Skubal generally would take his time in other circumstances, the potential of a salary cap means he and agent Scott Boras should be uniquely motivated to sign a contract before the collective bargaining agreement expires.

So where does that leave the Mets?

Well, frankly – a little bit over a barrel. Two things can be true at once: 1. Signing Skubal to the expensive, long-term contract he desires is likely to be a poor financial decision. 2. They need to do everything they can to make it happen anyway.

Let’s look at the first part of that. Skubal is the front-line ace that anyone would be happy to have on his roster, but signing a pitcher to a contract of this nature is intrinsically risky. They get hurt, and even if they don’t, the deal is certain to depreciate as he ages, meaning a team is essentially banking on a financial hit.

Though not speaking about Skubal directly, Mets owner Steve Cohen addressed this back in September. (And remember that however he feels about free agency in general probably counts doubly so when it comes to pitchers, where the focus on optimization and max effort has at least partially led to decreased durability.)

“Free agency is a negative expected value,” Cohen said then. “It just is. If you’ve got to constantly dip into free agency and you do it enough, that can come back to bite you…It would be my preference (to build a team via the farm system) but if you have to fill in holes, you’ve got to fill in holes, too. You’ve got to be tactical but every time you dip into free agency, you know that’s a tough place to be.”

But no one is going to pay Skubal $400 million because he’s “worth” $400 million. They’ll pay him that because that’s what the market dictates. And right now, the Mets have all but painted themselves into a corner: First, there was the 2025 implosion, followed by this past season’s $345 million humiliation ritual. Throughout, president of baseball operations David Stearns has been lambasted for high-risk decisions that failed to pan out, along with an adamant refusal to sign a true ace to the types of long-term contracts that true aces are bound to command.

In other words, Skubal's value is more than his "worth." Stearns' previous experiments have failed – especially when it comes to their rotation. Sure, they have a lot of promise in young pitchers like Nolan McLean and Christian Scott, but thrusting a guy like McLean into an “ace” position so soon can be detrimental to his development, and doesn’t allow him the luxury of learning under more established talent.

Meanwhile, signing Skubal means having a built in stopper – the sort of looming, devastating presence the Mets have missed since the halcyon days of Jacob deGrom. It gives them credibility they very much need.

If you stuck around long enough to pay attention to the last few months of 2026, you would have noticed that things weren’t as dour as they were in, say, June. The youth movement imbued the team with a sense of fun and optimism. You saw improvement in players like Bo Bichette, and promise in some of the bullpen arms that were called up after the trade deadline fire sale. Manager Andy Green capably steered them toward respectability.

Suddenly, a year filled with players holding tearful interviews in front of TV cameras was instead replaced by acceptance of what they could not change, and a determination to fix that they could. You don’t want to squander that, and you don’t want to sink this coming season any further into the abyss.

So, sure – it won’t be easy. There’s no doubt the Dodgers gave Skubal plenty to think about when they acquired him midseason. The Blue Jays became a hot destination after their 2025 World Series run. Under new ownership, the Padres, too, look like a fun place to land.

But the Mets have money, and they should have a spark of desperation about them. Is it a financially sound idea? Almost certainly not. But worth and value are different things, and by signing Skubal, the Mets can make a statement they should have been making all along.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME