Newsday's All-Long Island girls lacrosse second team 2025
Clockwise, from top left: Sabrina Boyle, Caitlin Barnes, Delaney Chernoff, Amelia Brite.
Caitlin Barnes, Islip, M, Jr.
The Boston College commit had 44 goals and 23 assists.
Sabrina Boyle, Huntington, M, Sr.
Boyle had 48 goals, 16 assists and 95 draw controls for the Long Island Class A champions, including two goals and an assist in Huntington’s 12-8 win over Massapequa to win the title. She is committed to play at Binghamton.
Amelia Brite, Commack, M, Sr.
The Florida State commit had 61 goals and 12 assists in a 16-2 season for Commack. She had four games with at least five goals.
Delaney Chernoff, Long Beach, M, Sr.
She had 38 goals and 25 assists while being a force at the draw circle. The versatile Chernoff is committed to play at Denver.
Annie Chimienti, South Side, A, Sr.
She led Nassau Conference I with 89 points on 33 goals and 56 assists, including two games with more than seven assists for the Nassau Class C champions. Chimienti is committed to play at Canisius.
Abigail Dieumegard, Islip, G, Jr.
The athletic goalie was tied for fifth in Suffolk in saves (137) while frustrating some of the top scorers in the nation in Suffolk Division II. She made 11 saves while stopping 68.8% of shots against state Class C champion Bayport-Blue Point in a 5-3 loss.
Cady Flaherty, Sacred Heart, M, Sr.
The Virginia commit had 43 goals and 10 assists as a key part of Sacred Heart’s defense.
Top row, from left: Annie Chimienti, Abigail Dieumegard, Cady Flaherty. Middle row, from left: Paige Garguilo, Alexia Giannakopoulos, Brianna Henke. Bottom row, from left: Lyla Ingrilli, Catherine Karman, Page Kellershon.
Paige Garguilo, Massapequa, M/A, Sr.
She had 42 goals and 28 assists for the Nassau Class A champions. The Jacksonville commit had five goals in an 11-9 win over Port Washington in the Nassau Class A final, tying a season high.
Alexia Giannakopoulos, Manhasset, D, Sr.
The Virginia commit never made anything easy on the opponent despite constantly going up against the best scorers on Long Island in Nassau Conference I.
Brianna Henke, Rocky Point, G, Sr.
The UMass commit had 119 saves while challenging the elite scorers in Suffolk II.
Lyla Ingrilli, Wantagh, D, Sr.
The Maryland commit was integral to Wantagh’s defense for the Nassau Class C runner-up. Her speed, athleticism and 1-on-1 defense made her one of the toughest players to score against on Long Island.
Catherine Karman, Port Washington, M, Sr.
Karman led Port Washington to its first county final since 2018, highlighted with a four-goal performance in a 16-7 win over Syosset in the Nassau Class A semifinals. The Virginia Tech commit had 42 goals and was one of the top players on the draw.
Page Kellershon, Mattituck, M, Jr.
She was tied for seventh on Long Island with 89 points on 58 goals and 31 assists for the Suffolk Class D champions. Kellershon, a Navy commit, had three goals and three assists in a 13-6 win over Babylon in the Suffolk Class D final.
Clockwise, from top left: Marlo Knox, Brooke Mazzei, Liliana Pettit, Ava Obloj.
Marlo Knox, St. Dominic, M, Jr.
She was second in the CHSAA in goals (64) and points (81) for the CHSAA Class AA runner-ups. Knox, who also was pivotal on the draw, led St. Dominic to its first Class AA final in program history and is committed to play at Florida State.
Kylie Lamoureux, Rocky Point, M, Sr.
The Maryland commit had 50 goals and 17 assists while also being key defensively and on the draw.
Brooke Mazzei, Lynbrook, M, Sr.
The athletic Mazzei had 53 goals and 19 assists and is committed to play at Temple.
Ava Obloj, West Islip, M, Jr.
The Florida commit had 35 goals and 28 assists as a balanced offensive threat.
Liliana Pettit, Commack, M, Sr.
She had 44 goals and 26 assists to finish tied for 13th in Suffolk in points. Pettit is committed to play at Stony Brook.
From left: Katherine Rathjen, Emma Speed, Colleen Thieke.
Katherine Rathjen, St. Anthony’s, A, Sr.
The Florida State commit was fourth in the CHSAA in points at 50 goals and 17 assists for the state CHSAA Class AA champion. She had three goals and an assist against St. Dominic in the final.
Jolie Schiavo, Smithtown West, M, Sr.
The James Madison commit had 39 goals and was integral on draw controls and defense to help lead Smithtown West to its first Suffolk Class B title in program history.
Emma Speed, St. Anthony’s, A, Jr.
Speed led St. Anthony’s in goals (51), assists (24) and points (75) as a dangerous offensive weapon for the No. 1 ranked team in the nation. She is committed to Florida.
Colleen Thieke, Sacred Heart, M. Sr.
The Virginia Tech commit was sixth in the CHSAA in points (54) on 36 goals and 18 assists.
