Wyandanch boys soccer's Justin Escalante makes most of late opportunity in Suffolk All-Star game
Justin Escalante of Wyandanch passes during a Suffolk senior All-Star boys soccer game on Wednesday, Nov. 17, 2026 in Central Islip. Credit: Dawn McCormick
Wyandanch’s Justin Escalante attended the tryouts for Suffolk’s All-Star games but left without one of the 68 spots allocated for the county’s top seniors.
Then the phone rang. Someone had dropped out.
“I was next man up,” Escalante said. “I get to be here.”
So, when Wednesday night finally arrived, under the lights at SUSA’s Orlin & Cohen Sports Complex in Central Islip, Escalante seized the moment with the goal of the evening, ripping a beauty from at least 35 yards out into the top right corner of the net.
“It’s amazing, man,” Escalante said. “I get to play another game, get another highlight and just keep moving forward.”
Escalante was one of many who came to Suffolk’s senior All-Star Games with the hope of impressing college coaches while representing their high schools one last time.
Patchogue-Medford coach Tim Trava, who coordinated the event alongside Commack’s Dave Moran, said 40 college coaches registered to attend, with more watching via livestream. The event, which has been run for over 40 years, featured players from 38 different Suffolk high schools.
“For a couple years, some kids didn’t want to play,” Trava said. “Now all the best play, and that’s the best part. I think getting college coaches down here [made the difference].”
Trava said the link to the game gets emailed out to “about 400 college coaches and recruiting services” on Thursday. The money from the event went toward NYSPHSAA-run scholarships.
Escalante’s red team, named after Glenn coach Lou Hanner, lost, 5-3, to Team Cashman’s blue team, named after former North Babylon coach Mike Cashman.
East Hampton’s Esteban Diaz, Northport’s Cameron Fischer, Half Hollow Hills West’s Elijah Prywes, Lindenhurst’s Gianni Lombardo and West Islip’s Charlie Basini all scored for Team Cashman. Basini also assisted Prywes’ score off a well-executed give-and-go.
“It was fun, really competitive,” Prywes said. “It’s all the best people from high school.”
Mount Sinai’s Sam Covington of Team Hanner scored with a low shot to the bottom right corner and assisted Center Moriches’ Marquise Miles later after beating his defender along the left wing.
The second game began with a moment of silence for the late Brentwood coach Ron Eden, who died in July after battling prostate cancer. Team Eden faced Team Sebi — named after former Commack coach Sebastian DiRubba — with Team Sebi winning, 2-1. Commack’s Ryan Curcio scored the go-ahead goal with a terrific volley in the second half.
“I take it as an honor,” Curcio said. “I thank Coach Moran and all these other coaches that supported me throughout the whole season. I thought this was one of the best moments.”
Mattituck’s Cris Cuellar kept a clean sheet in the second half and made a terrific stop against Jaxson Weber of Sachem East, a teammate of his on the club level. Alexis Gomez Hernandez of Patchogue-Medford opened the scoring before Huntington’s Ezra Oddoye equalized for Team Eden.
Prywes and Curcio both had advice for those looking to play in the all-star game in future years.
“Just train every day,” Prywes said. “That’s what I do. It really helped me with my development and make big improvements.”
“You got to work hard,” Curcio said. “There’s no exception to that.”

