Farmingdale football coach Buddy Krumenacker, No. 2 on Long Island all-time wins list, calls it a career
Farmingdale football coach Buddy Krumenacker on Nov. 4, 2026, in his final year before retiring. Credit: Newsday/John Paraskevas
It’s the end of an era.
Farmingdale football coach Buddy Krumenacker walked off Hofstra’s Shuart Stadium field one last time Sunday afternoon. The legendary coach saw his 58-year career end in an 18-14 loss to Oceanside in the semifinal round of the Nassau Conference I playoffs.
“It was a tough run at Hofstra the last few years,” Krumenacker said. “In a place like Farmingdale you believe you can win all the time. There’s obvious disappointment when you lose."
Krumenacker closes a stellar career with a record of 322-108-11 over 45 years. He guided the Hempstead program to a 77-19-5 record from 1978-1988. He went over to Farmingdale and replaced a retired icon in coach Don Snyder. The program didn’t skip a beat. As Krumenacker would say, “I kept the train on the tracks."
He would lead Farmingdale to a 245-89-6 mark from 1993-2026.
Imagine that one high school football program was led by only two head coaches over the past 74 years.
Pete Nazario has served as Farmingdale’s quarterbacks and defensive backs coach for the past 19 years. Ironically, he played for both Snyder and Krumenacker. Nazario was the quarterback for Snyder’s last season in 1992 and Krumenacker’s first season in 1993.
“It’s been very emotional the last couple of weeks,” said Nazario, a two-year starter at quarterback for the Dalers. “He’s been intense and really trying to stay focused. But we could tell it was on his mind. The last few days, his walk-ins to practice were a bit slower, he was sitting in the office a little longer. He knew this was inevitable. We walked onto the field on game day and he said, ‘this may be my last day walking in,’ and not that we thought we would lose but that statement really hit me.”
Krumenacker, 79 years old, who graduated from Ball State University in 1969, soaked in the final weeks. He was early to practice, really enjoyed his time on and off the field with the staff and working with his players.
The district named the varsity field in his honor this fall. It is now Buddy Krumenacker Field at Don Snyder Stadium.
“This place will always be special for me,” Krumenacker said. “They understand what we do here. There is joy in winning, but it is expected here. Our goals were always to impact our guys in a manner that the life lessons would be carried with them into their lives. And I think we’ve done that.”
Under Krumenacker’s leadership, the Dalers made 31 playoff appearances, won nine Nassau Conference I titles, and two Long Island Class I championships in 2001 and 2022. He is the second winningest coach in Long Island history. Bethpage’s Howie Vogts had a 364-124-10 record over 56 years.
“He’s been thinking about this for quite a while,” Nazario said. “It’s not going to be the same around here. It was an amazing experience to watch his leadership over the years. He’s never changed his intensity and always been a father figure to the coaching staff and the players. He’s always had everyone’s back. We knew it would come to the end. Hard to believe it’s here.”
The same man who built the Hempstead football program from the ground up came to Farmingdale and replaced an icon and sustained the level of winning the Dalers faithful expected.
Krumenacker was a treasure before Farmingdale. He led Hempstead to four Rutgers Cups and five consecutive Nassau titles from 1984-1988.
“He’s been a role model for all coaches,” Massapequa coach Kevin Shippos said. “His teams were always prepared and were all about class, excellence and toughness.”
Krumenacker announced in August that he was all in for one more ride with his Dalers. He knew the season would eventually end.
“It’s been a great ride,” Krumenacker said, while collecting equipment and saying goodbye to his players Monday afternoon. “It’s an emotional time. I’ll still be around. I’ll be at the games. But it was time.”
