Anthony Asaro of Garden City leaps into the end zone...

Anthony Asaro of Garden City leaps into the end zone for a rushing touchdown during the fourth quarter of the Nassau Conference III football final against Carey on Friday, Nov. 20, 2026, at Hofstra. Credit: James Escher

When the Garden City and Carey football teams met in October, Anthony Asaro stood on the Trojans’ sideline, watching his offense set up a go-ahead field goal in the final seconds of a one-point win.

The senior running back and linebacker was nursing a hamstring injury and Garden City’s coaching staff held him out to make sure he was healthy for the playoffs.

He looked as healthy as ever Friday afternoon at Hofstra’s Shuart Stadium.

Asaro rushed for 167 yards and two touchdowns on 25 carries and added two sacks to help the top-seeded Trojans to a 31-21 win over No. 2 Carey in the Nassau Conference II final. Garden City has won 11 straight Nassau titles and 31 county crowns overall.

“It was tough, not being out there in that game,” Asaro said. “I wouldn’t miss this for the world. This is our last opportunity to win a county title. Even if I had a broken leg, I wouldn’t miss this game.”

Garden City (10-1) will face Northport in the Long Island Class II title game at noon on Friday at Hofstra. The Trojans have won five straight Long Island championships.

Asaro made his presence felt early, recording a third-down sack to force a punt on Carey’s opening drive. Ten plays later, he ran left and jumped into the end zone for a 6-yard touchdown.

“He wasn’t happy when we didn’t let him play that game in the regular season, but it was the right decision,” coach Dave Ettinger said. “I’m so happy that he got to play at this stage and have a great night like he did.”

Justin DePietro’s 27-yard scoring run in the second quarter tied the score at 7.

Mark Escher kicked a 21-yard field goal with 28.6 seconds left in the second quarter to send the Trojans into halftime with a 10-7 lead.

On the first play of the third quarter, Brayden Robertiello faked a handoff to Asaro, rolled to his left and uncorked a deep ball over the middle to an open Kosta Walsh, who made the catch and ran into the end zone for a 69-yard touchdown and a 17-7 lead.

“It was an awesome play call and we executed it perfectly,” Robertiello said. “Kosta made a great catch. Great blocking. It gave us so much momentum out of halftime and I think that propelled us to win the game.”

“Not everyone can roll one way and throw a beautiful ball the other way like Brayden did,” Ettinger said. “Kosta ran a great route. We don’t throw on first down often, but we took a shot with it there and it worked.”

Carey (9-2) got within 17-14 when David Avila caught a screen pass from Gunnar Nelson and made two defenders miss on his way to a 15-yard touchdown with 8:32 left in the third quarter.

But Garden City answered with a four-play, 83-yard drive capped by a 3-yard scoring run by Christian Roddini for a 24-14 lead with 6:17 left in the third quarter. Robertiello broke a 50-yard run and Asaro added a 23-yard run on the drive.

Max Siragusa’s interception set up a nine-play, 60-yard drive that ended with Asaro’s second touchdown and gave Garden City a 31-14 lead with 11:56 remaining in the fourth quarter.

After David Blot made a diving grab of Nelson’s 6-yard touchdown pass in the back of the end zone to cut Carey’s deficit to 10 points with 8:17 left, the Trojans stayed on the attack.

Garden City ran 11 plays and reached Carey’s 34-yard line before a fourth-down pass fell incomplete with 2:49 remaining. The Trojans took 5:28 and all three of Carey’s timeouts off the scoreboard.

“It starts with all the big guys getting down and dirty in the trenches and playing smashmouth football,” Asaro said.

Then AJ Haffner had a sack and Asaro and Will Curley combined for another sack as the Trojans forced a turnover on downs.

DePietro had 13 carries for 78 yards and a touchdown and added seven tackles for Carey. It was the final game of his outstanding four-year career.

“He’s a super-talented player and a fierce competitor,” Ettinger said. “He’s as good on defense as he is on offense. He’s a game-changer. He willed them back into the game. He’s an awesome player.”

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME