Winnipeg Jets goaltender Nico Dawsthrows his stick as he gets...

Winnipeg Jets goaltender Nico Dawsthrows his stick as he gets caught out of his net as the Uslanders' Emil Heineman scores during the first period of an NHL hockey game in Winnipeg, Manitoba, on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. Credit: AP/John Woods

WINNIPEG, Manitoba — It wasn’t one of the Islanders’ best outings this season, not when they couldn’t hold or build upon three one-goal leads.

“This is a tough game for us to play,” coach Pete DeBoer said. “We were out West last week. Came home. Came all the way back out here again. I thought our legs were probably a six or seven out of 10 tonight.”

Nor was there a signature moment like, say, Matthew Schaefer’s first career hat trick in the previous game. Or Simon Holmstrom’s first career three-goal performance two games ago.

But it was enough to earn them a point in a 4-3 overtime loss to the Jets on Thursday night at Canada Life Centre. The Islanders pushed their point streak to a season-best six games (3-0-3) even as their winning streak was snapped at three games.

Defenseman Josh Morrissey scored the winner at 1:58 of the extra period.

“I don’t think we played a bad game,” defenseman Adam Pelech told Newsday. “They’re a good team. They have a lot of talent up front. We just, unfortunately, couldn’t get the job done tonight. It just kind of felt back and forth. It felt like a good, even hockey game.”

There was further concern over Ryan Pulock’s availability as he did not play in the third period because of an apparent lower-body issue and the Islanders finished the game with five defensemen. Pulock was playing his fourth game after a four-game absence as he aggravated a shoulder injury that required offseason surgery.

“They’re getting used to it,” DeBoer said of the Islanders’ consistent injury issues this season, adding that he’d have no update on Pulock until he was examined by a team doctor. “We’re playing a man down I feel like almost every night. I thought they did a good job. Being down a man and them pushing, we bent but didn’t break. I thought Varly made a couple of huge saves in the third in order to get the point.”

Semyon Varlamov, in his 600th NHL start, made 18 saves for the Islanders (10-6-5). His best came in the third period to keep the score at 3-3 as he went into a split to deny Brayden Yager and stopped Cole Perfetti after he was sprung to the crease.

Perfetti’s power-play goal at 12:09 of the second period had erased the Islanders’ final lead.

Former Devils goalie Nico Daws, acquired after three-time Vezina Trophy winner Connor Hellebuyck finally forced his way out of Winnipeg, stopped 22 shots. He suffered a 6-0 loss to the Islanders at UBS Arena on Oct. 3 while still with the Devils.

“When we got to our game and forechecked hard and kept our game simple, we created chances for ourselves, so we’ve just got to get back to that a little bit,” Bo Horvat said. “It’s frustrating and we need to be better [in holding the three leads]. But to at least get a point on the road feels better than nothing.”

The Jets (11-9-3) gifted two goals to the Islanders.

Daws misplayed the puck directly to Emil Heineman for a shorthanded goal as the Islanders took a 2-1 lead at 8:44 of the first period. Daws flung his stick — which would have resulted in an automatic goal — in a futile effort to prevent Heineman from scoring into the open net.

Then defenseman Dylan Samberg turned the puck over deep in his zone as a wide-open Kyle Palmieri made it 3-2 just 20 seconds into the second period with his fourth goal of the season and first in 10 games.

“As a group, there’s things we could have done better,” Palmieri said. “Closed a little better. Broke out a little cleaner. For the most part, it was just a tight game. It felt like a close-checking game. I thought Varly played a great game. We tried to get some sustained offensive-zone time but we were kind of moving it around the outside. We were having trouble penetrating into the really good scoring areas.”

Casey Cizikas, expected to play his 1,000th game on Saturday in Detroit, set up Anthony Duclair’s goal for a 1-0 lead at 2:35 of the first period.

Jean-Gabriel Pageau returned from a three-game absence because of a lower-body injury and DeBoer used him to center the fourth line, with Cizikas sliding to left wing.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME