Rex Ryan on the set of ESPN's Sunday NFL Countdown...

Rex Ryan on the set of ESPN's Sunday NFL Countdown on Sept. 27, 2026. Credit: ESPN Images/Gerald Leong

On Nov. 11, former Jets coach Rex Ryan turned himself in to Nashville police and was arrested for allegedly running over the feet of two pedestrians with his pickup truck and leaving the scene in a Nov. 5 incident.

Four days after he was charged with six misdemeanors, Ryan was in his usual spot as part of the panel on ESPN’s “Sunday NFL Countdown.” He did not mention the arrest, nor did he the next day during ESPN TV and ESPN New York Radio appearances.

On July 23, CBS lead NFL analyst Tony Romo was arrested by Milwaukee police and charged with operating a vehicle while intoxicated. The NFL was not in season. Eight days later, CBS placed Romo on an indefinite leave. He did not appear again on the network. On Oct. 2, the sides announced that they were parting ways.

Why did CBS react they way it did to Romo’s arrest and why did ESPN react the way it did to Ryan’s arrest?

There are no clear answers. But there are theories. Among them:

  • Romo’s stature as the top analyst on CBS’ NFL games with a 10-year, $180-million contract was more high-profile than Ryan’s role as a participant on a panel;
  • Romo’s transgression – for which he pled no contest on Sept. 1 and blamed in part on “an over-reliance on alcohol” because of chronic back pain – was partially captured on video that appeared to show Romo was intoxicated.

As of now, there is no video of the Ryan incident, in which he is alleged to have run over the feet of two pedestrians with his pickup truck before arguing with the pedestrians and then leaving the scene. Ryan, who was later identified by his license plate, “HIT QBS,” was charged with two counts of leaving the scene of an accident, two counts of failure to give information or render aid and two counts of failure to obey a traffic control signal, according to court records.

None of the charges suggest alcohol was involved. Ryan is scheduled to appear in court on Dec. 18.

Ryan’s Nashville attorneys David and Ben Raybin said on Nov. 11: "From the outset, Coach Ryan has been fully cooperative with law enforcement, and he intends to remain fully cooperative as this matter moves forward. Because this case is in its early stages, we currently have limited information regarding the allegations. We will conduct a thorough investigation and address the facts through the appropriate legal process."

  • CBS had time to deal with the Romo situation since it occurred in the NFL offseason. ESPN had much less time to decide if Ryan should remain on the air after his arrest.

ESPN has released two statements on the Ryan incident. On the day of his arrest, ESPN said: “We are aware and are in touch with Rex.”

On Saturday night, hours before he was set to appear on the network’s pregame show, ESPN said: “As of now, Rex will appear as scheduled, including on Sunday NFL Countdown.”

The “as of now” in that statement appears to be doing a lot of work. It indicates that ESPN, which is owned by Disney, could change its corporate mind if new details appear that embarrass either Ryan or the company.

"Every network contract with talent, and with most executives, includes a clause that addresses ‘moral turpitude’ and its consequences,” Dennis Deninger, a Syracuse professor emeritus of sport management and sport communications, former longtime ESPN executive and author of the book ‘Sports on Television: The How and Why Behind What You See,’ wrote in an email to Newsday.

“The network would consult with its attorneys to determine which lines were crossed and the appropriate punitive actions. The fact that the charges against Tony Romo involved driving while impaired, which can be a lethal danger to the public, very likely weighed heavily in the CBS decisions.

"ESPN and its legal team have to make their own judgments based on the severity of the misdemeanor charges against Rex Ryan. It's possible that further action could be taken if or when he goes to court."

Greg Bouris, sport management professor at Adelphi and former head of communications for the Islanders, Florida Panthers and Major League Baseball Players Association, said: “I would assume the way these megamedia conglomerations are established now that when a high-profile celebrity runs afoul of the law -- guilty or innocent -- that that is handled at least on the legal side up to the highest level to get some kind of consensus on the direction to take. Meaning I don't think this is a decision made by the production team.”

Should ESPN have taken Ryan off the air? Should CBS have been so quick to dissociate itself from Romo? These are the questions network executives had to grapple with in real time.

“From what I've read, the [Ryan] situation seem to be distinctly different,” said Bouris. “One was an impaired driving incident in Romo's case that was clearly caught on camera and shared almost instantly on social media . . . The other one is quite different where, based on the information I've seen, that this could have been an accident. Maybe he was aware and not aware of, I guess, running over somebody's feet. At that stage, it's an accusation. So I think ESPN is doing the right thing in Ryan's case and letting the legal process play itself out because there are some unknowns perhaps. You kind of have to let the facts surface through the legal process.”

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME